Election Eve Special Edition: State of Election Data
Few doubted that the Trump administration would do everything in its power to preserve Republican majorities in the House and Senate, but our Data Security team has been troubled by how big a part data abuse has played in its vote suppression plans. In case you haven’t been following the shenanigans, we’ve put together an Election Eve summary of what’s happened, and what it might mean for the 2026 and 2028 elections.
There’s precedent from the first Trump administration: In 2017, Trump signed an executive order to create a Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity, which requested unredacted voter rolls from all 50 states. Most states refused the request, the administration was sued over the commission’s authority, and the commission was shut down after less than a year with nothing to show for its efforts.
This time, the administration’s increasingly aggressive attempts to pry voter data away from states have forced election officials to play constant defense, but mostly failed to achieve the aim of disenfranchising voters. With hours to go until Election Day, the administration still lacks complete voter data for most states, and the Post Office’s restrictive new ballot mail regulations have been blocked by the courts as ballots are delivered across the country.
The citizenship database debacle
The Department of Homeland Security’s SAVE (Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements) program was created to allow officials to check immigration status when people apply for benefits. Even for that limited purpose, SAVE data has always been unreliable. But the Trump administration is trying to use it as the basis for a national database of Americans’ personal information they could use to disqualify more people from voting. To that end, DHS has consolidated data from other government agencies — including the IRS, the Social Security Administration, and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services — into the already flawed SAVE program.
Eighteen states voluntarily turned over their voter rolls to be compared with the national database. But, in an echo of 2017, the DOJ has failed to compel unwilling states to turn over data on their voters. Courts have ruled for the states in all 27 of the 31 lawsuits decided so far, and the administration has lost its first appeal in a case against Michigan as well.
The administration is still trying, in increasingly desperate ways, to get voter data from counties, towns, and commercial data brokers. But for the November 2026 general election, the administration doesn’t have the data to allow it to “check” voters’ eligibility en masse. And an October ruling by a federal judge prevents the Department of Justice from demanding unredacted voter lists from states to check against SAVE.
In the last weeks before the election, activists uncovered a desperate effort by DHS to consolidate partial voter data from public and commercial sources to identify supposed noncitizens. The DOJ also sent error-filled lists of voters to California counties demanding they set aside the listed people’s ballots, and followed up with a lawsuit where it demanded an instant ruling and then attempted to escalate to the appeals court before the district court had ruled. The courts still aren’t having it, so far.
Still happening: Some individual states may opt to check individual voters against SAVE after the Supreme Court paused enforcement of the same federal judge’s June ruling blocking its use.
The attempted Postal Service workaround
In August, the USPS issued new regulations that mandated strict guidelines for the design of ballot envelopes and required states to submit a list of voters they intended to send ballots to. The Post Office said that they would refuse to deliver any ballots that didn’t match the list exactly. A federal judge blocked USPS from implementing the policy during the 2026 election, specifically. The Supreme Court upheld that injunction, effectively shutting that policy down — for now.
Nevertheless, some states are recommending that voters use drop boxes or return their ballots well in advance of November 3.
There will be more lawsuits over the Post Office’s authority to regulate ballot mail and the federal government’s role in elections.
Looking ahead
We can anticipate the administration will still try to intimidate voters and will interfere with the 2026 election once votes are cast — and we fully expect another effort to implement restrictive policies and use shoddy data to disenfranchise legitimate voters in the 2028 election. But for now — thanks largely to intensive efforts by civil society orgs and state attorneys general — voting is on track to proceed as it has in earlier years, excessively long lines and all.